February 6, 2014

Pound Cake IngredientsWhen I received a gift of fresh (raw) cream last week, my first thought was pound cake. You see, I knew the cream would become butter. And then the butter would become cake. And when I returned from the market with some beautiful Arucana (blue) hen eggs, well, that was just the nudge I needed.

I am a big fan of pound cake. I’ve made dozens of different recipes, but I’m here to tell you: Edna Lewis’ pound cake is perfection. And the beauty of the recipe is in the simplicity. Butter, eggs, flour, sugar, vanilla and a little lemon. I bet you have all of those ingredients in your house right now.

Edna Lewis BooksI first encountered Miss Lewis’ pound cake in her terrific book, The Taste of Country Cooking. If you haven’t read this book, please do. It’s one of the classics – a must read for anyone who loves food writing. (It was edited by Judith Jones, Julia’s editor!) The curious instruction to put the cake in a cold oven – and gradually increase the temperature over the course of an hour – captivated me. And from the very first time I made it, I was sold.

Pound Cake 1I’m not sure when the pound of flour, pound of sugar, pound of butter meme came about, but this recipe has nothing to do with pounds of anything. Edna Lewis declared success was certain with “a slow oven, cold butter, carefully measured flour, and the patient mixing of butter, sugar, eggs, and flour” in this Saveur article.

Pound CakeIn subsequent recipes for pound cake she changed a few things and I’ve tried them all, but I come back to the first, the original, recipe every time. The one that starts in a cold oven. There are links to the recipe here and here.

When you bake it, start the cake in a cold oven, turn the temperature to 275°F for 20 minutes. Increase to 300°F for the next 20 minutes, then finish the cake at 325°F for 20 to 30 minutes, or until a cake tester comes out clean as a whistle. It’s nice to make in a fancy Bundt pan, but a tube pan works well, too. I haven’t had success with a loaf pan, so don’t do that.

Sliced Pound CakeThe cake will keep for a week in a tin. I like to toast it for breakfast, or spoon lemon curd or strawberry rhubarb sauce over a slice at teatime.

Homemade Butter
Makes: 8 Tablespoons (4 oz., the equivalent of one “stick” of butter), and about 8 ounces (one cup) of full fat buttermilk

2 cups heavy cream
1/4 teaspoon kosher or sea salt, optional

  1. Whip the cream using the whisk attachment of the stand mixer or a hand mixer. It will go through several stages, foamy, then frothy, then soft peaks and stiff peaks and eventually, butter. Start at medium speed and increase to high. It will take anywhere from six to 15 minutes until the butter separates from the buttermilk and it starts to spatter. Alternatively, shake the cream in a wide-mouth quart jar with a tight fitting lid. Shake and shake and shake until butter forms and separates from the buttermilk, about 15-25 minutes.
  2. Pour the buttermilk into a container. You should have about a cup. (This makes exquisite biscuits or pancakes.)
  3. Over a colander in the sink, make a ball of butter and wash it under cold running water. (Is the butter too soft? Float it in a bowl of ice water for 20 minutes, then continue.) Working under  running water, squeeze and form the ball of butter again and again to remove all the buttermilk. Once the water is running clear from the butter in your hands, knead firmly to remove all the moisture.  Salt the butter if you wish.  Wrap in wax paper and store in the refrigerator. Use within a week.
    Homemade Butter

9 Responses to “homemade butter for perfect pound cake”

  1. Rory

    I have read and enjoyed everything I can by and about Edna Lewis and have made her recipe for baking powder many, many times. I am not familiar with this coffee cake but plan to rectify that this weekend. I am very curious about baking the cake in cold-to-increasingly-hot oven. Thanks.

    • Char

      Just a note of correction: Not coffee cake – pound cake. A world of difference! How did yours turn out? I hope it was sooooo gooood!

  2. Lana @ Never Enough Thyme

    I find butter making particularly enjoyable with the homemade version far superior in taste to anything ever purchased from the grocery store. Thank you for including the washing step as so many online instructions either gloss over or outright skip that part not realizing that any buttermilk left in the butter will cause spoilage.

    I completely agree that Edna Lewis’ pound cake recipe is divine! Her books are treasures that occupy a special place on my shelves.

  3. crystal

    Hi there – LOVED your talk at FoodBlog South – was great! Quick question – the two links you share have very different recipes – one has cream cheese and one doesn’t? Which recipe do you actually use? Thanks

    • Cathy

      Crystal, Thanks for asking – My favorite recipe is in the very first link in the post – the one that points back to an earlier post I did on the pound cake. The other recipes are equally wonderful, but that first one is the original. Let me know if you make it!

  4. bellingtonfarm

    I have all of Edna Lewis’ books (did my research paper on her for a culinary class!). She was a tremendous influence on Alice Waters and those of us who love using fresh from the farm ingredients! The pound cake is everything you’ve described – AND MORE!! It’s a fabulous recipe and I’m glad you’ve posted it here for others to enjoy.



  1.  Cold Oven Pound Cake | Customer
  2.  Cold Oven Pound Cake - Lake Murray Pets

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.